Auction Watch: Antiquorum’s ONLY WATCH 2011 Results

Auction Watch: Antiquorum’s ONLY WATCH 2011 Results

Auction Watch: Antiquorums ONLY WATCH 2011 Results   sales auctions

As expected the ONLY Watch 2011 went without a hitch last week. It raised € 4.5 million, about USD $ 6,075,000 as of this writing. Let's take a look at some of the results. [see all of the watches: studio pics & in-the-flesh, hands-on]

Antiquorum Auctioneers - The collection of unique 40 timepieces achieves € 4.5 million at the Only Watch Charity Auction: Monaco, September 24, 2011 - The fourth edition of the biennial Only Watch Charity Auction held at the Hotel Hermitage in Monaco on September 23, in the presence of H.S.H. Prince Albert II of Monaco, closed with an outstanding result of EUR 4'563'000. The auction room was full in addition to the strong internet and intense telephone bidding. International participation included Japan, Switzerland, Hong Kong, China, the United States and the Russian Federation. Ronnie Wood from the Rolling Stones was also present in the room to support the auction.

Auction Watch: Antiquorums ONLY WATCH 2011 Results   sales auctions

Perhaps the most controversial piece was the Patek tourbillon / minute repeater, Ref. 3939, Lot 30. The "Wish Price" for this dream piece was €450,000 - €650,000. It went for €1.400.000, about USD $1,890,000! There were a lot of haters for this piece. It's perhaps the least-flashy of the watches in the auction. It's from a manufacture that some consider old and stodgy. It's in stainless steel, which is particularly odd for a Patek. And the size? It's only 33.3mm! So whomever won this piece has a great gift for his wife.  Auction Watch: Antiquorums ONLY WATCH 2011 Results   sales auctions All that said, it's still a phenomenal finish for this watch.

Lot 23 was the Ikepod Hour Glass. A couple weeks ago I wrote:

"I say timepieces and not watches if for no other reason than the always iconoclastic Ikepod is presenting an hourglass (lot #23) for 2011! It's a limited edition of one (see non-limited flavor). It's fantastic. Something a little different from one of my favorite brands. The "Wish Price" for this item is 15,000 - 25,000. Compared to the other items in this auction the hourglass is a steal. And you'll never need to get it serviced as long as you never drop it."

Looks like their estimate nailed it. And we were correct about this item being a deal compared to much of the rest of the auction.

Auction Watch: Antiquorums ONLY WATCH 2011 Results   sales auctions
And what of Lot #28, the MB&F Horological Machine No.4 Thunderbolt “Flying Panda?” Earlier, I wrote:

The two large horizontal cones/tubes that are the displays remind the wearer of the A-10 Thunderbolt warplane. The two pods look like jet turbines. And the "Flying Panda" angle? Well, there's a small panda sitting atop the watch holding reigns, not unlike Ben-Hur on his chariot, or even Santa on his sleigh. Make no mistake, it's an odd combo, but if anyone has the horological street-cred to pull it off, MB&F does. The details: manual wind, twin mainspring barrels, and 50 jewels. The "Wish Price" for this item is EUR 170,000 - 230,000.

This MB&F finished at € 170,000, frankly, rather disappointing in my opinion. I really could have seen this easily hitting €250,000, especially considering that these official estimates of hammer prices are intentionally low. Was it the economy? Maybe collectors move to the finest houses in economic downturns and times of certainty. That explanation would at least seem to partially explain the amazing result for the Patek.

Let's check out a few of the other pieces and their results ...

Lot 2: Bell & Ross, BR01 Casino
Wish Price: €20.000 to €40.000
Result: €18.000
Analysis: A bit of a disappointment. Though I don't find it surprising. I find all of the poker and gambling-related watches to be rather gaudy and quickly-dated.

Auction Watch: Antiquorums ONLY WATCH 2011 Results   sales auctions

Lot 5: Bovet, Amadeo Dragon & Phoenix
Wish Price: €180.000 to €220.000
Result: €70.000
Analysis: "Ouch" would be an understatement here. Bovet is one of those "newish" brands that has tried to conjure up a rich and deep aura around itself. Pascal Raffy has become a watch industry celeb second only to maybe the Great J.C. Biver.  In my opinion, this may be due partially to the fact that we are talking about a pocket watch. I don't particularly care how well-heeled one is. If you drop tens of thousands on a watch, you're going to want to wear it at least a few times. And unless you're decked-out in morning dress, in 2011 a pocket watch is a bit of an affectation. The €70.000 here has to be a bit of an embarrassment no matter how you spin it.

Lot 11: Corum, Golden Bridge
Wish Price: €55.000 to €70.000
Result: €50.000
Analysis: A little low. This watch has a bit of the Richard Mille look that has been popular of late. I expected this to go for a bit more.

Lot 16: Franck Muller, Crazy Hours
Wish Price: €20.000 to €40.000
Result: €44.000
Analysis: Franck Muller pieces continue to be popular. I don't get it.

Auction Watch: Antiquorums ONLY WATCH 2011 Results   sales auctions
Lot 38: Van Cleef & Arpels, Jules Verne From The Earth To The Moon Poetic Complication
Wish Price: €100.000 to €150.000
Result: €215.000
Analysis: Wow, never saw that one coming. Not really my personal taste, but a beautiful piece nonetheless.

A final thought on the diminutive Patek. Years ago a man's watch was full-sized at 36mm, then later at 38mm. Over the last decade we've seen this creep upwards of 45mm in many cases (yes, Panerai and Graham, we're looking at you). You would have to go upwards of 45mm before many people would today raise their eyebrows and wonder if a watch was simply too big. I guess 45mm is the new 38mm? So it's not like Patek has offered a 37mm watch here and it's being called small. 33.3mm is REALLY small. I wonder if this could be a new trend bringing us back to case-size sanity? I think it's worth noting that purely from an engineering standpoint, putting a tourbillon and minute-repeater into a 33.3mm case is much more of a feat than doing so in a 48mm case.

And let's look a bit more at the steel issue. The Patek, far and away the highest priced item here, is stainless steel, as is the Ulysse Nardin “Freak Diavolo.” Is this a new trend in high-end watches? Or more appropriately, is it coming back into vogue. I think that the use of stainless steel in expensive watches was first done bu Audemars Piguet with their Gerald Genta-designed Royal Oak circa 1972. Traditionally, fine watches are offered in gold or some other precious metal. Is steel back?

Here are the top 10 watches in terms of final hammer prices:

Watch US Dollars
Patek Philippe, Ref. 3939 $1,910,720.00
Richard Mille, RM 027 Tourbillon Rafael Nadal $696,048.00
DeWitt, Concept Watch No. 3 X-Watch $559,568.00
Bernhard Lederer, Gagarin Tourbillon $409,440.00
Van Cleef & Arpels, Poetic Complication $293,432.00
MB&F, HM4 Thunderbolt Flying Panda $232,016.00
Harry Winston, Midnight GMT Tourbillon $218,368.00
Ulysse Nardin, Freak Diavolo $170,600.00
Breguet, Grande Complication $163,776.00
Vulcain, Skeleton Cricket $156,952.00

 

Auction Watch: Antiquorums ONLY WATCH 2011 Results   sales auctions

The Patek, Gagarin Tourbillon, Breguet, Chanel, Celsius, Franck Muller, Frederique Constant, Piaget, Ulysse Nardin, and Van Cleef & Arpels all beat their estimates. Of the forty watches in the auction, nearly half (18) failed to hit their minimum estimate. Overall, I think that while the auction did raise a great deal of money for charity, and gave the manufactures some fine P.R., the results show the realities of the world's financial woes.

14 comments
Alex
Alex

The PP reminds me of the 250 California Spider #2377 that went for € 6,400,000 some years ago. Bidding war between 2 people who didn't want to accept defeat by just bidding on a big name (well two actually, Ferrari and James Coburn). Ridiculous prices that will screw up the collector's market even more. Think about it, you could a 5207 AND a 5208 for the price of this piece alone. And the reason why this watch has a steel case is simply because the standard 3939 is not available in that material.

Frank
Frank

Good read and nice to see an opinionated article about the OW results. It was a very 'interesting' result... and I agree with the conclusion that the financial climat is probably the reason for the relatively low results and also a reason for people to move towards save investments like Patek.

Dean Grant Baker
Dean Grant Baker

there's actually NOT a lot of gold or other precious metal in a watch; a gold Rolex weighs 147 grams that's about 5.25 ounces or about 8 500 USD, assuming the entire watch is solid gold; including caseback; crystal and movement.
--------------
And a few years back gold as worth far less.

Yoyo Ma
Yoyo Ma

Not to knock the Patek but 1.9 mil for stainless steel???

kris.c
kris.c

I don't think there will be a trend toward small or steel for the most part, I believe the minute repeater was done in such a material because that is most appropriate for hearing the complication.
I am in awe that the Diavolo went for that price. It's still #1 (or near to it) on my list, and this one of a kind looks to have been sold for less than an original design, or Rolf 75 version. Interesting. Can't help but think I'd want to just snap off that silly "only watch" license plate though.

The Bovet 'dissapointment' is pretty funny actually: that thing couldn't be any uglier
, and serves as a great example of how taste will dictate buying, regardless of applied effort or skill. It can have all the best artistry and complication available, but if it ends up ugly as all hell, good luck enticing the masses.

Gerald
Gerald

The Patek 3939 looks horrible, with such a small diameter, and is probably just dust and humidity proof, and not water resistant. Yet, over here in Singapore, we went up to U$1M before giving up. While I admire Patek's beautiful work with its movement, I really wish Patek could have given it a much bigger case, my 2 cents anyway...

admin
admin

Just got a lot of good Only Watch gossip from some people were there. The Patek was in steel cause that is "rare" for Patek. No other reason. I just got to play with a Ulysse Nardin Freak Diavolo and will do a review in the near future. Love that piece.

Jerry
Jerry

You are probably correct in assuming the Patek is not water resistant.....most minute repeaters are not. If they were, the chime would not sound properly. Nobody buying this watch would take it swimming anyway. In regards to the size, its pretty amazing they fit that movement into a 33mm case dont you think. Yes i agree a bit small, but better overly small than overly large.

sorry i had to reply.....

Dean Grant Baker
Dean Grant Baker

As to mbn'f; told ya so; man; that's actually embarrassing.

Frank
Frank

The reason for Patek to make the Tourbillon Minute Repeater in steel is indeed to improve the sound quality and loudness of the small gongs. Because gold is a weaker material it absorbs the resonance more than steel.

Dean Grant Baker
Dean Grant Baker

you're right in your conclusion; and if it were NOT for the PP this charity auction would have been a disaster.

Is steel back? As long as gold stays near 2K an ounce -- yup.

Dean Grant Baker
Dean Grant Baker

and it does NOT look like a jet; it looks like B&L binoculars.

Trackbacks