back to top

Carl F. Bucherer Patravi ScubaTec Manta Trust Limited Edition Watch Review

Carl F. Bucherer Patravi ScubaTec Manta Trust Limited Edition Watch Review Wrist Time Reviews

Many divers and dive-watch enthusiasts share a strong love of the sea and a desire to protect the world’s oceans and the denizens of the deep. To this end, Carl F. Bucherer offers an intriguing diver that combines a thoroughly modern and capable dive watch with a direct line of support to manta ray conservation: the Patravi ScubaTec Manta Trust Limited Edition. Your purchase of one of the 188 limited-edition pieces aids — you guessed it — the Manta Trust, an international trust based out of the UK that supports manta ray conservation through research, education, and collaboration. If this cause resonates with you, you’re in luck, as these sorts of watch-and-philanthropy partnerships, if done right, can be a win for the brand, the consumer, and the charitable organization.

Subtle this watch is not: with two manta rays gliding across the dial and a third on the caseback, you’d better have a soft spot for these gentle giants. Rather than another throwback vintage-style diver, you’re looking at an unabashedly modern diver, with its message and cause on proud display. If you’re looking for something under-the-radar, this watch ain’t for you. The same holds true if you’re looking for an instantly recognizable icon in the genre. Let’s face it, the $5,000-$10,000 sport/dive watch market is packed with classic offerings from household names. Ask for suggestions in this price bracket, and chances are you’ll hear Rolex Submariner, Omega Seamaster, or some of the other usual suspects: Panerai, Breitling, JLC, etc. Unless you’re having this conversation in Europe or Asia, one brand that likely won’t be immediately mentioned is Carl F. Bucherer. And that’s a shame.

Carl F. Bucherer Patravi ScubaTec Manta Trust Limited Edition Watch Review Wrist Time Reviews

Lucerne-based Bucherer has been around as a family-owned business since 1888 and certainly has plenty of history, not to mention horological cred — from developing a peripheral rotor in their in-house A1000 movement to upping the ante by combining a peripheral rotor with a peripherally mounted tourbillon in their novel T3000 movement. While the Carl F. Bucherer Patravi ScubaTec Manta Trust Limited Edition may not house those horological innovations, what it does provide is an interesting alternative to the usual suspects and one with an abundance of personality and an excellent story to tell.

Carl F. Bucherer Patravi ScubaTec Manta Trust Limited Edition Watch Review Wrist Time Reviews

Originally released in 2013, the ScubaTec dive watches sit within CFB’s Patravi line that includes chronograph, dive, and sport watches. While Carl F. Bucherer may be best known for their high-end offerings, whose prices often gravitate toward the astronomical end of the spectrum, the steel versions within the ScubaTec line are more, if not affordable, at least attainable without the sale of vital organs. Nestled within the line of ScubaTec watches is the Manta Trust Limited Edition. Instantly recognizable by its deep gray hues and two manta rays gliding across the dial, this limited edition was created specifically as a way for Carl F. Bucherer to help support manta ray and ocean conservation through collaboration with the Manta Trust. Given that the connection to the Manta Trust is central to the design and, for many potential buyers, the motivation to purchase this watch, let’s learn a bit more about the organization.

Carl F. Bucherer Patravi ScubaTec Manta Trust Limited Edition Watch Review Wrist Time Reviews

UK-based Manta Trust is a registered charity aimed at conserving manta rays and other mobulid rays through their three pillars: research, education, and collaboration. With a broad global distribution, protecting rays across such a vast geographic area requires exceptional coordination among researchers, NGOs, governments, and other stakeholders in order to gather critical research and information and to enact conservation measures. And this is exactly what the Manta Trust does. I spoke with Dr. Guy Stevens, CEO of the Manta Trust, and here’s how he described why the organization is focusing on manta rays, specifically: “I see manta rays as a flagship species. [Mantas] are extremely captivating, they’re beautiful to look at. They’re something people really seem to connect to and care about. Because they’re big and they move about the coral reef environment, they need a lot of space. By proxy, protecting mantas equals protection of the coral reef ecosystem in which they live.”

If you’re wondering why a company like Carl F. Bucherer would decide to get involved with ocean conservation, Dr. Stevens explained, “I genuinely feel that, right up to their CEO, they are doing this because they want to help us, and that’s important to me. Yes, we get the funding and they can help us spread our message, but I wouldn’t want to partner with an organization that was only doing it for purely profit reasons. I don’t get that sense from them at all. It’s been a good relationship and I’m hoping it will carry on for many years to come.” Of course, we consumers have become understandably skeptical when it comes to product tie-ins with philanthropic organizations. We want to know that the money is actually funneling back to the charity. Rest assured that this money is directly benefiting the Manta Trust.

Carl F. Bucherer Patravi ScubaTec Manta Trust Limited Edition Watch Review Wrist Time Reviews

I asked Dr. Stevens specifically how this partnership has benefited his organization. He said, “The first thing [Carl F. Bucherer] did is fund a couple of satellite tags that we deployed on oceanic manta rays in Mexico. Over the years, we’ve picked various small initiatives. The money tied into this watch [the CFB Manta Trust] was for ongoing research activity in the Maldives that’s part of a Ph.D. program to look at the feeding behavior of these animals. They funded several staff members to go out to the Maldives, plus accommodation while they were there, research equipment, and analysis of various samples. That was a significant chunk of money and work that we wouldn’t have been able to finance without their support. We’re trying to ensure that the money we get goes a long way toward achieving our goal.”

After learning about the Manta Trust and speaking with Dr. Stevens, Carl F. Bucherer and the Manta Trust seem like a perfect fit. Now, that’s all well and good, but let’s get to the watch itself and see if it’s a worthy tribute to this partnership.

Carl F. Bucherer Patravi ScubaTec Manta Trust Limited Edition Watch Review Wrist Time Reviews

The case of the CFB Manta Trust is big and bold at 44.6mm and sports a 22mm lug width. Luckily, some of the girth is offset by a manageable 13.45mm height and, while the lugs are proportionately long at ~51mm, they slope steeply and hug the wrist. The case features beefy lugs, strong angles, and details that all shout at being overbuilt and capable, including screwed lugs, bolt-on crown guards, an oversized screw-down crown, a prominent helium escape valve, and 500m of water resistance. The Manta Trust is a modern diver, through and through. No fauxtina or box crystals here. Speaking of which, the crystal is a flat sapphire with well-applied AR coating on both sides. One small detail I love is that both the crown guards and the helium escape valve are a darker, gunmetal hue — presumably a PVD coating. It’s a small touch, but one that adds another complementary element to the piece, unifying the deep gray on the dial and bezel with the case, itself.

Carl F. Bucherer Patravi ScubaTec Manta Trust Limited Edition Watch Review Wrist Time Reviews

CFB went with a deeply grooved sandwich crown accented with a black spacer. It’s easy to grip and has the smooth winding action you’d expect, but it accomplishes this feat with an added bit of pizazz. Unfortunately, the oversize crown was the one part of the watch that caused some discomfort, occasionally digging in. This wasn’t a huge issue, and I wasn’t left with any indentations on my skin, but it’s something to note. The composition of the bezel is interesting, with two tones of ceramic filling in the spaces surrounding the prominent steel markers and numerals that seem to provide the scaffolding of the bezel. It’s an interesting juxtaposition to the typical feeling of numerals and markers floating in a sea of ceramic. The 120-click, unidirectional bezel is easy to grip, and the action is smooth, but a bit light for my taste. Luckily, I never had a problem with the bezel being inadvertently knocked out of place.

Carl F. Bucherer Patravi ScubaTec Manta Trust Limited Edition Watch Review Wrist Time Reviews

Before we move onto the dial and caseback, consider this scenario: Twenty meters under azure waters off a Maldives atoll you spot them: two unthinkably large manta rays, wings undulating in the water. As you watch, a cloud passes in front of the sun, casting the water into a deep gloom, the mantas barely visible in the half-light until the sun re-emerges, throwing the creatures into stark relief. This experience is almost tangible as you gaze at the dial, watching the manta rays appear and disappear in the changing light. The undersea sensation is enhanced by the horizontal texturing that grabs light, creating depth and texture, evoking sunrays filtering through the water, bringing the manta rays to the fore in direct light and casting them back to the depths as the lighting and angles change. It’s a mesmerizing effect that really needs to be experienced in person. Frankly, when I saw the press photos of this watch, I wasn’t sure how I felt about the overt co-branding, with the manta rays playing such a prominent role on the dial. Worst case, I worried that it might suffer from the “Pimp My Ride” effect — too much of a good thing that diminishes the whole. I’m happy to report that this is, in no way, the case and, in fact, the manta rays and the textured dial turned out to be one of my favorite elements — a fun, quirky addition that adds loads of character and, much like the rest of the watch, plays with the light in surprising and unexpected ways.

Read more about

Watch Brands

Explore

Comments

Disqus Debug thread_id: 7244135387

  • Swiss_Cheese

    It may be because I’m 12 at heart, it may be intentional design, but does anyone else think the hands look a bit like an alien phallus?

  • Sheez Gagoo

    Is this the watch from MEG?

  • Martin Francis

    I have always liked chunky dive watches; there, I’ve said it, my secret is out….. A chunky dive watch with a fine linked purpose is doubly enticing. Can I quibble about some of the detailing ? Maybe, just a little, but the overall aesthetic works fine for me.

    • Independent_George

      Thick and chunky divers have their fans. I think WUS has a continuing thread just for chunky divers, it has 1000s of posts and has been going strong for years.

      I looked at CFB Scubatec watches last year because liked the blue dial on the rubber. A little too chunky for my tastes, but if you are into that, I don’t think you can go wrong. And the street price should be closer to $5000 than $7000.

      • Martin Francis

        Understood, I think I had to take a deep breath and ignore the price and simply consider the watch as is. It is beyond my resources which does not stop me enjoying it and I do not seem to be alone. If I win the lottery, who knows…..

    • Larry Holmack

      Well…I do like chunky divers myself….but…I’d rather have it in a 51 mm from 9-3 and closer to a 60 mm from lug to lug myself. But..I know not everyone has Hulk Hogan sized wrists….and for those that do…well…we have plenty of choices.
      Don’t be a hater…I can’t help it if I am a giant sized guy!!

      • Martin Francis

        No problem Larry, we’re not all the same size and whilst I think your measurements rather overshadow mine, I can entirely see your point.

  • DanW94

    Waaay to much watch for a desk diver like myself, but I like it nonetheless.

  • Tony NW

    It’s cool looking, a little over-the-top and cartoonish. The largish sizes and yet attention to detail seem steam-punkish, excepting the high finish and materials. But it is quite large.

  • PR

    This watch is not as popular for a reason, it’s absurd. They have had the standard edition for years and have not really made an attempt to make it more appealing. The watch is too big, too heavy, runs an eta, and is priced beyond reason and you have to cut the strap on your 6k watch!

    . If you want a shiny diver there is zero reason to buy this over a Breitling superocean or the new Seamaster for significantly less. They literally do everything better.

  • I guess if you’re into the Save the Manta Rays thingy, check out for 1/10th of the price, ETA based 2824 and almost the same dimensions albeit the generous thickness, the Prometheus Manta Ray with the white or black dial & the Oceanic Time Manta Ray LE, both variations have DLC coated titanium casings The Manta Rays & the scuba diver engravings on the caseback are pretty neat

  • Pete L

    I really like this but find the dial design a little distracting. The standard collection has a lovely textured dial and that combined with the manta on the back would be a better balance for me.
    Came close to buying the white dial version last year and gutted I didn’t pull the trigger as it was a great deal and they continue to grow on me. Will keep an eye out on the bay! Great review by the way.

  • Jon Heinz

    Well, now that you guys pointed out the hands and what they look like…

    Other than that, I see nothing wrong at all with this: it’s not an homage of anything but not TOO “unique”, it’s a pretty clean presentation. ETA workhorse but it’s chronometer cert at least, and maybe other mods too as mentioned. Anything that goes to protect living things can’t be bad either, right?

    • Berndt Norten

      It’s a livin’ thing
      It’s a terrible thing to lose
      It’s a PR thing
      But everyone’s free to choose

      • Larry Holmack

        Sweet…making an ELO reference!!

  • TheChuphta

    Or you could buy a Seiko Sumo, get an in-house movement, donate $5.5K to charity, and still have enough left over for a nice lunch with friends. From where I’m sitting, $6k for a generic movement, on a rubber strap, from a relatively obscure brand is preposterous.

    • Independent_George

      Sure, if you like your in-house movements loud and inaccurate, your bezel slightly unaligned, and if you if don’t mind the crystal and bezel scratched beyond recognition in a few years, go for it!

      Look, I think Seiko divers are the best value proposition in mechanical watches, but comparing this to a Sumo is far from an apples to apples comparison, other than they are both mechanical dive watches.

      And Bucherer watches are from for obscure in Europe and Asia.

      • Raymond Wilkie

        I think you missed the point George.

      • TheChuphta

        Yikes! Sorry, Mr. Bucherer. I didn’t know you were in the room today.

      • Polerouter

        I don’t know. I live in Switzerland, and CFB are very famous as watch retailers, not so much as a watchmaking company. Still, I find it funny to mention “Europe and Asia” as if it were pretty specific. Europe and Asia ARE the world’s swiss watch market. Well, 84% of it.

    • aWtchslvr

      Agree that it is overpriced. This is not original. Most of the brands are overpriced. But the comparison with the Seiko Sumo… please.
      A Grand Seiko, Seiko Astron, Seiko Padi and CFB owner.

  • Raymond Wilkie

    Exactly how much of my 6k I going to save flipper?
    All this buy me for ( insert charity ) and save the planet drives me nuts.

  • Mikita

    Actually, C. F. Bucherers loose >50% on secondary market:

    https://www.chrono24.com/carlfbucherer/patravi–cheapest-price-in-chrono–id9685268.htm

    My colleague got one Scubatec black-red for $2,800.